Apr 08, 2014 recently i dug out the query to set up a demo on sql server 2014 and something strange happened. The general assumption is that most of the queries will be benefited by new cardinality estimation introduced in sql server 2014. In a previous blog, i talked about sql 2014 s new cardinality estimator new ce and trace flags 9481 and 2312 can be used to control which version of cardinality estimator is used in this blog, i will modify a real scenario customer hit to show you that how you can use these trace flags to spot issues related to new ce and how sql 2014 sp1 can help. Mar 28, 2018 cardinality estimation concepts in sql server march 28, 2018 by dmitry piliugin in this blog post we are going to talk about the principles and the main concepts which are used by the optimizer to perform an estimation, and also, we will do a little bit math, so be prepared. New cardinality estimation logic microsoft sql server. A black box approach to query cardinality estimation. Hekaton or as microsoft marketing likes to call it, inmemory oltp, updateable columnstore indexes, and buffer pool extensions are some of the more common enhancements. To give you a concrete example of where the cardinality estimation has problems, imagine the following 2 tables. The new cardinality estimator steve henrys sql server tips. Im looking to learn more about tuning queries that were written in sql 20082012 to work with the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator. The cardinality estimation logic has been redesigned in sql server 2014 to improve the quality of query plans and ostensibly, query performance.
From sql server 2014, the new cardinality estimator was introduced for database compatibility level 120 and greater. Cardinality estimation ce in sql server is derived primarily from histograms that are created when indexes or statistics are created, either manually or automatically. Jun 01, 2016 the sql 2014 cardinality estimator eats bad tsql for breakfast. Cardinality estimation in sql server dba from the cold. Cardinality estimation sql server sql server microsoft docs. Download microsoft sql server 2014 express by clicking the appropriate link earlier, run it, and follow the instructions in the setup wizard to install. One of the new features of sql server 2014 is the consideration of correlations between column values in the estimation of cardinality for a query plan. The discrepancy between estimated and actual values is significant, generated execution plans are suboptimal and execution details are 5 50x worst compared to the old ce plans. Oct 08, 2017 from sql server 2014, the new cardinality estimator was introduced for database compatibility level 120 and greater. Sql server 2014 cardinality estimator performance tuning.
Trace flag 47 to use minimum selectivity does not work in sql server 2014, if the new cardinality estimator is used when compiling a query. Identifying sql server 2014 new cardinality estimator. New cardinality estimation logic microsoft sql server 2014. In this article i will describe a case which is not properly handled by the new cardinality estimator, introduced in sql server 2014 ctp2. Sql server how to force new cardinality estimation or old. Sql server express with database engine only can work with either. In case the compatibility level of a specific database is set to sql server 2014 120 as shown below, the new ce is going to be used. Optimizing your query plans with the sql server 2014. Ive upgraded a preprod server from sql server 2012 to sql server 2014 sp1. The process of finding number of rows, those will be processed by an operator in query execution plan. Jul 01, 2014 this is the first of two posts on the new cardinality estimator in sql server 2014 sql server 2014 comes with a lot of shiny things. Use the following code to create and populate the test table the help.
All of this can be found in optimizing your query plans with the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator. New paper released on sql 2014 cardinality estimation sql shep. Sql server 2014 introduces new cardinality estimator. Cardinality estimation for correlated columns in sql server.
Aug 19, 2014 sql server 2014 has new cardinality estimation logicalgorithm. Any new database created on a sql 2014 instance will have a database compatibility level to match the instance versions i. Checking sql server query cardinality estimator version. And, similar to the case in this post i would interpret the behavior of new cardinality estimator in this case as a bug, too. May 15, 2014 if youve been following the blogosphere, or heading to sql saturdays, youll know that many folks are excited about the brand new sql server cardinality estimator ce for short.
The optimizer component has not changed since version 7 about 15 years. It is the essential component of sql query processor for query plan generation. Cardinality estimation in sql server 2014 datavail. May 14, 2014 sql server 2014 includes a new cardinality estimator. Sql server 2014 cardinality estimation sql in sixty. Apr 14, 2014 ive been working on writing a new microsoft white paper since january covering the main changes made in the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator, and happy to announce that it was just published. Alter database scoped configuration sql server transact. One of the performance improvement in sql server 2014 is the redesign of cardinality estimation. Nov 06, 2014 in this article i will describe another query pattern where new ce in sql server 2014 brings significant regression. New cardinality estimation logic in sql server 2014 improves performance of queries. It has been largely good however, in our brief manual testing we have found some issues where the new cardinality estimator has made significant decreases in performance on a handful of queries. In this article i will describe another query pattern where new ce in sql server 2014 brings significant regression. Aug 19, 2014 new cardinality estimation logic in sql server 2014 improves performance of queries. Sql server 2014 will make use of its newly rewritten cardinality estimator when the databases compatibility mode is at least 120.
That is why the generic advice is to set the compatibility level of the. Take into consideration that upgrading the current sql server engine to sql server 2014 or restoring a database from previous sql server versions will not change the compatibility level of the existing databases and will not enable the new cardinality estimator automatically for these databases. In a previous blog, i talked about sql 2014s new cardinality estimator new ce and trace flags 9481 and 2312 can be used to control which version of cardinality estimator is used in this blog, i will modify a real scenario customer hit to show you that how you can use these trace flags to spot issues related to new ce and how sql 2014 sp1 can help. Sql queries can timeout or your configmgr console can run slow because of the new cardinality estimator ce changes in sql server 2014 and sql server 2016.
Note to make the fix take effect for the second issue described in this article, enable trace flag 4199. Remember, there is no 0 or 1 logic when it is about estimation. Wrong cardinality estimation p foracle may 18, 2014 2. Big performance problems with the cardinality estimator sql. However, database restores, database attaches, and even inplace upgrades from earlier versions leave the database at its original, older compatibility level. Cardinality estimates in microsoft sql server 2014. The problem got so bad at one point that the decision was made to revert back to the old cardinality estimator by enabling the 9481 traceflag and updateing statistics again. When you run a query that contains join statements, you may encounter the following issues. Cardinality estimation in sql server nov 4, 2014 dbafromthecold each time you view a seekscan operator in an execution plan, you may have noticed that theres a value for the estimated number of rows and a value for the actual number of rows.
Introduced in sql server 2016 was the use hint query argument. New cardinality estimator sql server 2014 is way off. It gives you the option to use the new ce or use the legacy ce as it existed before the changes were made in 2014. Recently i dug out the query to set up a demo on sql server 2014 and something strange happened. If youve been following the blogosphere, or heading to sql saturdays, youll know that many folks are excited about the brand new sql server cardinality estimator ce for short. What i am going to try and do is to document what you wont find in these articles. In this blog post ill show methods that can be used to identify and troubleshoot query plan regressions caused by the new cardinality estimator. The new cardinality estimator is based on indepth cardinality estimation research based on what microsoft has seen and learned over the past 15 years. All of this can be found in optimizing your query plans with the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator a redesigned cardinality estimator in sql 2014 has been implemented to improve the quality, performance. Join containment assumption in the new cardinality.
The presql server 2014 ctp2 query plan was as follows via sql sentry plan explorer, showing estimated rows. Sql server 2014 some queries very slow cardinality. Since alter database scoped configuration is a new feature in azure sql database and sql server starting with sql server 2016. Ill show how this was a very manual task in sql server 2014 and how the process was made much. This means your specific sap application workload should be tested thoroughly per system when upgrading to sql server 2014 and using the new cardinality estimator. Jan 03, 2014 in this article i will describe a case which is not properly handled by the new cardinality estimator, introduced in sql server 2014 ctp2. Setting the database compatibility level is the official way to use the pre2014 cardinality estimator in sql server 2014. Ive been working on writing a new microsoft white paper since january covering the main changes made in the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator, and happy to announce that it was just published. More problems with sql 2014s new cardinality estimator. This logic was not updated for quite a while, but in the latest version of sql server 2104 this logic is redesigned.
This represents a significant update and can potentially provide your environment with a huge performance boost. Sql server how to force new cardinality estimation or. Lets recreate our usual sample table and populate it this time with 10m rows. Join containment assumption in the new cardinality estimator. Enabling the new cardinality estimator in sql server 2014. Assume that you have enabled the new cardinality estimatorin microsoft sql server 2014. Troubleshooting query regressions caused by the new. The cardinality estimation logic is responsible for quality of query plans and majorly responsible for improving performance for any query. Sometimes, sql server also uses constraint information and logical rewrites of queries to determine cardinality. May 15, 2015 for more information about sql server 2014 service pack 1 sp1, see bugs that are fixed in sql server 2014 service pack 1. And, similar to the case in this post i would interpret the behavior of new cardinality estimator in this case as a bug, too lets recreate our usual sample table and populate it this time with 10m rows. And here was the new version of the plan using the new cardinality estimator. Sql server cardinality estimation ce changes in sql server 2014, sql server 2016 and sql server 2017 on windows may cause performance issues with certain configuration manager queries in some environments.
Apr 23, 2014 there is a new cardinality estimator in sql 2014. Sql server 2014 cardinality estimation sql in sixty seconds. The new ce changes several assumptions from the legacy ce in the model that is used by the query optimizer when it estimates cardinality for different operators and predicates. This is the first of two posts on the new cardinality estimator in sql server 2014 sql server 2014 comes with a lot of shiny things. After a couple of weeks, there were problems with execution plans not properly estimating row counts. If youre lucky enough to be running sql server 2014, with the new cardinality estimator enabled, you may be able to confirm the bug by manually checking trace flag 2363 output for a fixed 100% selectivity estimation on a semi join, but this is hardly convenient. Later in this blog we explain how sap implements sql server 2014 for sap netweaver applications and how you can switch between the two versions of the cardinality estimator. Sql server 2014 cardinality estimation hello, first time poster and sql newbie. You can read more about ce changes in the white paper optimizing your query plans with the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator. Here is the syntax for enabling or disabling legacy cardinality estimation. In my environment we maintain an erp database that we had running in 2014 120 compatibility mode for over a year. For correlated columns in the 2014 ce, to derive cardinality we need to sort the filters according to their density, where the smallest density value is first. Curious about the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator. Big performance problems with the cardinality estimator.
Resolving sql server 2014 cardinality estimator errors. The new ce changes several assumptions from the legacy ce in the model that is used by the query optimizer when it estimates cardinality for. Sql server 2014 has new cardinality estimation logicalgorithm. You can see that at the leaflevel, the cluster index scan estimates remain the same, as does the consecutive compute scalar. In this quick demonstration to see how sql server 2014 compatibility improves performance. Sql server 2014 includes a new cardinality estimator. I wanted to drop a quick post to cover a few key points. Cardinality estimation table variable vs temporary table. Cardinality estimator microsoft sql server has implemented a significant change to the database engines optimizer with the introduction of an improved cardinality estimator in version 2014. Whats new in sql server 2014 cardinality estimator. We hope, of course, that this will tend to provide better plans and help our queries to run faster, however, the new estimation methods might in some cases yield inferior plans for queries when. Microsoft has given a solution to this problem here which suggests to apply an appropriate sql cardinality estimator ce compatibility level as shown in the table below. Link for that blog is mentioned below today we will see about how we can use new cardinality estimator for. Jul 22, 2014 if youre lucky enough to be running sql server 2014, with the new cardinality estimator enabled, you may be able to confirm the bug by manually checking trace flag 2363 output for a fixed 100% selectivity estimation on a semi join, but this is hardly convenient.
Actually cardinality estimation algorithms have been changed in sql server 2014 by microsoft on the basis of workload study since last several years. Sql server 2014 cardinality estimator for databases. Sql server 2014 includes a new cardinality estimator, and in this version, the old cardinality estimator is still available. Cardinality estimates in microsoft sql server 2014 teched. Sql server 2014s new cardinality estimator part 1 css. Optimizing your query plans with the sql server 2014 cardinality estimator research paper. The new and improved cardinality estimator in sql server. New paper released on sql 2014 cardinality estimation. The sql 2014 cardinality estimator eats bad tsql for.
Does new cardinality will improve performance of all of my queries. Sql server creates and maintains statistics for temporary tables, which lead to better cardinality estimation and optimal execution plan generation. Apr 01, 2014 one of the performance improvement in sql server 2014 is the redesign of cardinality estimation. Nov 28, 20 the pre sql server 2014 ctp2 query plan was as follows via sql sentry plan explorer, showing estimated rows. Trace flag 9481 is effective to do the same thing as at the time of writing. The sql 2014 cardinality estimator eats bad tsql for breakfast. Sqlrockstar thomas larock the real sql server 2014 power feature it may not be hekaton sqlrockstar thomas larock recall that earlier this year i did a 2part post on the new ce. A redesigned cardinality estimator in sql 2014 has been implemented to improve the quality, performance, and predictability of query plans. January 15, 2014 by paul white in sql optimizer, sql performance, sql plan. Hi friends, in our previous blog we have seen how we can use new sql server 2014 cardinality estimator for newly created databases under sql server 2014. All of those new features are there to improve performance.
Inmemory oltp, buffer pool extensions for ssds, and a new cardinality estimator can improve functionality and smooth out the workflow, but only if you understand their full capabilities. First published on msdn on apr 01, 2014 one of the performance improvement in sql server 2014 is the redesign of cardinality estimation. This section explains what a cardinality estimator is, why a new cardinality estimator was built, and how to enable the new and the old cardinality estimators. Some queries take significantly longer time to compile, especially when the query has a large number of joins. The component which does cardinality estimation ce is called cardinality estimator. Resolving sql server 2014 cardinality estimator errors by. Professional microsoft sql server 2014 is your comprehensive guide to working with the new environment. Mar 17, 2014 as delivered, sql server 2014 decides if the new cardinality estimator will be utilized for a specific database based simply on the compatibility level of that database within the sql server 2014 instance. Selectivity concept similar to cardinality estimation. As delivered, sql server 2014 decides if the new cardinality estimator will be utilized for a specific database based simply on the compatibility level of that database within the sql server 2014 instance. Sql server azure sql database azure synapse analytics sql dw parallel data warehouse the sql server query optimizer is a costbased query optimizer. In the following cases, sql server cannot accurately calculate. Solarwinds cardinality estimation errors can lead to the query optimizer making poor choices as to how best to execute a query and, therefore, to badly performing execution plans.
169 1186 463 503 797 375 69 1142 102 458 1170 360 28 540 935 41 1214 170 614 1368 856 698 132 1476 1250 1068 609 396 1392 603 1050 1085 779